Staincross Apiaries

Ivy Honey and Winter Starvation: A Warning for Beginners

Ivy honey catches a lot of beginners out. It comes in towards the end of the year, it can be a very heavy flow, and nobody warns you about it. I want to share what I’ve seen, because losing a colony you could have saved is miserable.

Why is ivy honey different?

If you’re new, you’ve probably had your summer flow. Then comes the usual lull. Then out comes the sun, the ivy flowers open, and all of a sudden there’s a massive flow you weren’t expecting.

Ivy honey granulates very quickly. Often before it’s sealed. And it goes properly solid. That isn’t always a problem for wintering bees, but sometimes it is, and I think it comes down to the conditions.

You won’t find much about it in the books, and plenty of new beekeepers learn from books. Some experienced beekeepers dismiss it as a non-issue. I’m giving you my experience, and it’s always been a variable.

How to tell the ivy flow is on

In good weather the flow can last three to four weeks, usually September into early October. The ivy in the trees and hedges hums with insects. Wasps, hornets, hoverflies, bees, the lot.

At the hive, the bees hammer in and out and bring home a mid yellow pollen. On a calm, mild evening you can smell it. Quite pungent. If you’ve got a solid floor and a narrow entrance, you may also see water on the landing board in the morning. That’s moisture driven off the nectar overnight.

What’s happening inside the colony

Locally adapted bees, the non-prolific types, usually go off lay at this time of year, or at least cut back. Brood is hungry, so the colony needs less food. That leaves a lot of bees left over from the summer forage, and they store the ivy fast. A brood box can fill in next to no time.

Incoming nectar tends to start a queen laying, much as feeding does. So the queen can get crowded out as the box fills.

Why granulated ivy honey causes isolation starvation

Bees need water to liquefy granulated honey. In warm weather that’s easy. They break cluster, forage within the hive, move onto liquid food, and that gives them the water they need. So in a mild spell there’s usually no problem.

Cold weather is different. The bees cluster tightly and need food right next to them. They won’t cross a gap, even a small one between two boxes, or between the bottom of one frame and the top of the next. And they won’t cross a block of solid honey to reach liquid stores beyond it. You might think they must know it’s only two inches away. They don’t. They eat what’s close.

Then they starve, with food very near. That’s isolation starvation. I’ve seen a frame from a colony that went this way. A cluster of dead bees in the middle, solid granulated honey around them, the bees just starting to uncap it, and liquid stores about an inch beyond that they never reached.

Hefting can fool you too. A heavy hive feels well stocked, but if most of it is solid ivy honey the bees can’t use, you’ve got a false picture of what’s inside.

Don’t take the easy route

This is a topic where beekeepers disagree. Some have problems and others don’t. As with plenty in beekeeping, if somebody hasn’t seen something, they assume it doesn’t happen. If one person says there’s a problem and another says there isn’t, please don’t just take the easy answer. It may be fine this year and bite you next, or the other way round.

If the weather is poor while the ivy’s in bloom, not much comes in. And in a warm winter, ivy may be mixed in with liquid stores, perhaps from syrup you’ve fed. That’s usually a small problem. The trouble starts with a heavy flow, a solid block of ivy, no other forage, and then a long cold spell.

How to reduce the risk of ivy honey starvation

Here’s what can help. None of it is a total answer, but it may help.

You can put holes in combs so the bees can get from one comb through to liquid food. BIBBA has a video on how to do that. You can also feed syrup very gently at the same time, so you end up with a mosaic of ivy and syrup that the bees can work their way through. Or put a brood box underneath an existing one. If you’re lucky, you might even get some foundation drawn out.

Come November, have a look in your colony and see what you’ve got. BIBBA has a video on its website and YouTube channel on how to identify liquid stores, so please watch it first.

Please don’t lose a colony because somebody else said they didn’t have a problem. They might not have this year. You might. I hope this helps you save your bees.