Staincross Apiaries

Honey for Horse Wounds: What a Vet’s Research Shows

Honey on a wound isn’t a new idea. It was being used in ancient Egypt, and the Greeks and Romans had a go too. But it’s come back in a big way, and one equine vet has done some of the most interesting work on honey for horse wounds. I’ve pulled out the bits I think beekeepers will enjoy.

First, the sensible bit. I’m a beekeeper, not a vet. This is a summary of what a vet said in a talk to beekeepers. If your horse has a wound, ring your vet.

Why honey works on a wound

Wounds heal in the same way whether you’re a hamster, a horse or a human. The trouble is what gets in the way. The vet calls it bioburden. Dead tissue, bacteria, pus, and in a horse, bedding, muck and soil.

Honey helps in a few ways. It’s thick and pulls fluid out of the wound by osmosis, and that brings the dead tissue and discharge with it. It’s antimicrobial. It keeps the wound moist, which matters, because a classic bit of research on pigs showed that wounds kept moist and covered healed about twice as fast as ones left to scab over. And it seems to help the inflammatory and repair phases along. It’s even been shown to break down biofilms, which most antibiotics can’t get through.

He shows a horse wound that had sat for months, with a big pad of dead skin in the middle, going nowhere. After a medical grade honey dressing it was producing healthy pink granulation tissue within a day. In a week the dead tissue had gone and new skin was creeping in from the edges. That’s quite something.

Medical grade honey is manuka, for now

Honey dressings in human medicine are licensed as medical devices. The honey is filtered and sterilised with gamma radiation, which doesn’t seem to affect how it works. At the moment only manuka honey counts as medical grade. A handful of factories make most of the dressings, and they sell under lots of different labels.

Manuka’s special antimicrobial effect is put down to a compound called methylglyoxal, and the New Zealand industry has marketed it very cleverly. The vet points out that manuka sells to dressing makers for around £50,000 a ton. You know what your own honey sells for.

Why you shouldn’t use supermarket honey

This is the bit I most want you to remember. The vet’s team collected 33 honeys from around the world and tested them. Twenty were heavily contaminated, many of them ordinary supermarket honeys, and a couple carried nasty bacteria such as Proteus and E. coli. You don’t want that on your wound, or your toast.

Horse owners were being given expensive manuka dressings and then going off to the supermarket for a jar. The research says that’s a bad idea.

Heather honey did as well as manuka

Among the clean honeys, the findings were striking. Against nasty wound bacteria, including MRSA and Pseudomonas, Scottish heather honey appeared as effective as manuka, or close. Sugar syrup did little, so it isn’t just the sugar. Manuka 20+ worked at a concentration of just four percent, which matters, because wound fluid dilutes honey straight away.

The paper was the most downloaded in the Veterinary Journal in 2014. Heather honey is far cheaper than manuka, and we’ve got plenty of heather moorland here in Yorkshire.

When honey isn’t the answer

Honey isn’t always good. It’s best early on, in the inflammatory and early repair phases. Once the wound has healthy granulation tissue, honey can dry it out and slow things down. Proud flesh is usually a sign something else is wrong. Movement, infection, a foreign body, too much bioburden.

And he warns against a lot of what horse owners put on wounds. Purple spray, which he calls one of the greatest evils. Talc powders. Butter. His rule, borrowed from a colleague, is to put nothing in a wound you wouldn’t squirt in your own eye. That’s also why propolis tincture is no good in wounds. It’s alcohol based.

The kiwi test

One fun bit for the kitchen. Put a blob of thick honey, heather or manuka, on a cut kiwi and leave it 20 minutes. The fruit looks like somebody sucked the fluid out of it. That’s the osmotic pull working.

Could local honey do this job?

Around the world there are an estimated 120 million working horses, donkeys and mules, and their wounds are common. Flying manuka around the world isn’t cheap or friendly to the environment, so using local honey is attractive. There’s currently no evidence of resistance to honey either, though his team is testing that. Silver dressings, by contrast, now show some signs of it.

Don’t expect to sell jars to your local vet, though. He doesn’t think it will ever be a cottage industry. Regulation is tightening, and wound products should be licensed medical devices. The route is to show the research to dressing makers and persuade them to switch. Even then, one season’s honey might not match the next, so his team is testing for consistency, with schools and beekeepers taking part. Crystallised honey works as well as runny. Single source honeys seem more effective, though that’s anecdotal for now.

I’d love to see local honey proved useful here. For more on the evidence, the Cochrane site is a good place to start.